NY woman answers “American Ninja Warrior’ contestant’s plea, donates kidney to save girl’s life

ONEONTA, N.Y. — Amy Schlee was watching the NBC show “American Ninja Warrior” in July 2016 when she decided to donate one of her kidneys to someone she’d never met before.

“It’s something I’d researched doing in the past,” Schlee said in a phone interview with the Oneonta, New York Daily Star on Tuesday.

American Ninja Warrior” is an athletic game show in which contestants tackle obstacle courses that feature structures with forbidding names such as “the salmon ladder” and “the warped wall.”

On the episode that Schlee saw, however, a construction worker from North Carolina named Kenny Niemitalo made a plea on behalf of his baby daughter Hazel, who had been diagnosed with a congenital disease requiring a kidney transplant.

“How do I get the world saying, ‘this girl needs a transplant?'” Niemitalo said during the show.

“They had been unable to find a match,” Schlee said. “They were desperately seeking a new kidney donor.”

Schlee said that she actually happened on the segment at the tail end of the show, and began pursuing donation soon after that.

“It was one of those funny timing things,” she said.

When asked about why she chose to act, Schlee focused on what Hazel Niemitalo had been already been through.

“She spent the first nine months of her life in the hospital,” Schlee said.

The initial blood work for donation compatibility was done by the Bassett Healthcare Network, Schlee said.

“I was fortunate in that I’m O-positive,” she said, referring to her compatible blood type.

Schlee flew to Winston-Salem, North Carolina, where the transplant operation took place at Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center on Dec. 20, 2016.

Her transportation to Winston-Salem was provided by an organization called Angel Flight, which Schlee described as “wonderful people who donate their time and planes and money.”

Kenny Niemitalo had qualified for the next round of competition in San Antonio, an episode which aired on Monday night. Schlee could be seen in the audience, alongside Hazel and the girl’s mother, Maria. Schlee said that when she learned that Hazel was going to be there to see her father compete, she flew to San Antonio for the taping at her own expense.

Niemitalo finished just out of the top 15 finalists on Monday’s episode, conquering an obstacle referred to as “the pipe fitter” before finally falling prey to a trampoline-based contraption called “the hourglass drop.”

Schlee said that she recently ran a half marathon herself, in part to demonstrate what people can accomplish even after organ donation.

“I’m doing things I’ve never done before and I feel great,” she said.

Schlee has remained in touch with Kenny Niemitalo, she said. Niemitalo told her that Hazel, now two years old and doing well, was watching the show Monday too, but didn’t seem to recognize herself on television. Schlee said she is hoping that the family will come and visit her in the fall.

Schlee also said that she has wrestled with the question of whether to be public about her kidney donation.

“Do I do it and keep it quiet?” Schlee remembered thinking when considering the operation.

She eventually decided to speak more openly about her act, however, noting that there is “such a huge need” for organ donation. She cited a co-worker who had recently given a kidney to her nephew, and said that by talking about her experience, she is “hoping we can inspire a few more people.”

Benedict writes for the Oneonta, New York Daily Star.  

Community

Calendar for March 28, 2025

News

Ward is Chaplain of the Day in the House of Representatives

News

Measure to confront mass shootings, bomb threats, other school mayhem beats a deadline in the Senate

News

ABAC’s Georgia Museum of Agriculture to host Folklife Festival April 5

News

Second tort reform
bill passes both houses

News

Georgia Peanut Commission approves funding for research projects

News

Georgia Senate backs IVF treatments

News

Edwards named the
District’s Chief Academic Officer

News

Colquitt Regional receives awards from the Georgia Hospital Association

News

Former state Rep. Penny Houston to be honored with Advocate of the Year Award at children’s hearing event

Columns

EDDIE SEAGLE: A major adaptive gardening decision

Columns

HARRY MARTINEZ: Conflict within, Part 2

News

Turner’s Fine Furniture celebrates 110 years in business

News

Lawmakers decide to ban cellphones in public elementary and middle schools

News

Colquitt Regional adding women’s health residency program

News

Thoron named dean of ABAC School of Agriculture & Natural Resources

News

PCOM South Georgia
to host GOMA District III
annual meeting

News

State Senate gives locals extra leeway on property tax relief

News

Tort reform bill passes with support of Cannon and Watson

News

Downtown veterans
banners are sold-out

News

Guild wins awards
at district meeting

News

Lawmakers hear praise, concerns about legislation to stop school shooters

News

Ameris Bank donates $500,000 to Colquitt Regional

News

Possession charges with intent to distribute follow routine traffic stop